I made this last night I have to say I wasn't impressed. I'm familiar with a similar Middle Eastern dish called Lachmajou, however lamb is used instead of beef and only cinnamon for the spice. I'd omit the tomato paste and replace it with chopped tomatoes instead. The paste is very concentrated and overpowers the dish unless you add some broth or other liquid to mellow it out. Also, cooking it for only five minutes after the adding all those spices doesn't give enough time for the flavor to develop. Over all it tasted like ground beef with tomato paste. Sorry, just my opinion) I added sautéed garlic, a bit more salt and a little chicken broth to try to balance things out. The hummus was very good! However, I added extra garlic and olive oil.

Hi Michele G. Thanks for your feedback. As a founder, we love both positive and constructive feedback. This is a recipe that we have personally made over five times and everytime we've made it, people have raved about it. In fact, we made it just last night for 25 people and it lasted about 15 minutes. So while I'm a bit surprised, I'm more concerned that everyone has great experiences with our recipes.

So with this said, I'm wondering if anyone else out there has tried this recipe. At Rouxbe, we only feature the best of the best and we are more concerned about quality than quantity so I'd rather improve this recipe or delete it.

Floors open. Thanks again for sharing your comments Michelle.

Joe

In view of Michele's comments, I substituted 2 diced tomatoes for the tomato paste and put in a splash of white wine which had a nice deglazing effect (I like saucy dishes anyhow). I think the extra liquid helped the spices along. I also added extra garlic to the hummus, but that's really a personal thing isn't it? I think if I was making it for company I would have stuck to the amount of garlic suggested in the original recipe. I thought the spice amounts for the beef were perfect, and I'm really glad to have discovered this dish. Yum!

I can see why it would taste like beef with tomato paste, look at the amounts of the spice the recipe calls for.
I always laugh at recipes that call for something like 'an EIGHTH of a teaspoon of chili powder.'

I mean why even bother, 1/8tsp isn't going to do anything. IMO spices like chili powder and cumin should be used in denominations no smaler than a tablespoon. So, want the beef to have flavour? Add (ALOT) more cumin and chili powder and taste it while its cooking to test if it has enough flavour.

I followed the recipe exactly and thought it was really flavorful..You do have to limit on spices such as cinnamon and allspice for they are strong..Thanks for sharing this..I have gotten so many great recipes from this site...

This hummus recipe was fantastic. I couldn't get the special spice, but even without it I thought it made for a great classic hummus. Thank you.

this be made with something other than ground beef? I prefer my beef to be identifiable. Prehaps ground lamb, chicken or pork? instead? Just wondering.....

Good idea, ground lamb would be great, or any of the others you suggested. I particularly like the idea of the lamb though :-)

Thanks DT, I have made hummus on numerous occasions and will try this dish asap. I have a hankering for chili at the current moment so that is on the agenda for today. Tomorrow however is another story; thanks for the ok on the lamb, specifically which I particularly love.

I love putting a small touch of honey (or agave etc) into the hummus for that little extra "mmmm" that brings it over the top.

Pita or flat bread of some type would seem the most appropriate, maybe I am missing the obvious.

I was so excited to make this, but the results were less than impressive. I normally cook with a lot of garlic, and 1 clove of garlic doesn't sound like much, but it overpowered the hummus and that's all my husband and I could taste. Also, the beef wasn't spicy at all; it was very sweet. Very sweet meat with too much garlic - not a good meal. I was sad to have to throw the remainder away!

That your garlic was extremely fresh. When garlic is very fresh, it is far more pungent, and therefor more extreme in taste. Give the recipe another try, this time adding the garlic a little at a time. See what happens. I loved the recipe when I made it last year, actually more than a year ago. But it was great. JMO.

Why do we drain the all of fat in a sieve? In my humble opinion, that fat could be useful in cooking the contents in medium-low heat such as avoiding the contents to sticking to pan and furthermore add taste to final mixture. May be I am missing something? May be one reason is to avoid red colored oil(due to tomato paste) spilling on hummus which might damage the look and feel of the hummus plate. In any case, I am afraid we are losing some tasty juices by draining it in a sieve.

and although it is "lean" ground beef in the recipe, it is seldom a 96% lean mixture. Therefore, it is an unhealthy fat even if it might add "flavor". There are other ways to add the juice (use a separator) it will allow you to separate the fat and retain the juice. Good luck or as they say at Rouxbe Cheers!

if the objective is to create a delicous plate. Therefore, I believe there must be another "technical" reason to drain the "unhealthy" fat.

I do wish there was a separator that would filter out the unhealthy contents of the food from the flavored part , without losing taste :)

If the fat was not drained then the dish would be too greasy. If, after draining it, you want to save the fat and use it for another purpose then that is your right. That's the beauty of cooking, we are all free to do and make adjustments as we feel necessary, both for our flavor and for our health. Cheers!